Scientists often point first to temperature, not the recipe.
Research from the Cardiff School of Biosciences shows that any warm liquid, tea, broth, or hot water, can briefly loosen congestion and ease breathing.
Honey, by contrast, has firmer evidence behind it. JAMA Pediatrics reports that honey can calm irritated throats, and Verywell Health notes it can perform comparably to some cough medicines.
A review in Mini-Reviews in Medicinal Chemistry adds that honey may hinder certain microbes, though infants under 12 months must not consume it due to botulism risk.
Also read: Skincare expert explains how alcohol and smoking can show on your face
Lemon, alcohol and the limits of tradition
Lemon contributes only modest physiological benefits.
Analysts for the Cochrane Database of Systematic reviews conclude that vitamin C may shorten illness for some people when taken at symptom onset, but results vary widely.
Alcohol, despite its traditional role in a hot toddy, offers no healing advantage.
Alcohol Research emphasizes that spirits can worsen dehydration, meaning they contribute more to ritual than recovery.
Also read: Mask advice resurfaces as NHS capacity tightens and flu numbers climb
What experts recommend instead
Verywell Health highlights measures that target specific mechanisms: humidity to soothe irritated airways, a study published in Explore found that gargling with salt water may help clear the throat, and adequate hydration through warm fluids.
A study published in Flavour and Fragrance Journal showed that some people find brief relief from eucalyptus or peppermint oils.
Taken together, the research suggests the hot toddy’s value lies less in its folklore and more in how its components provide warmth, moisture and momentary calm.
Sources: Verywell Health, Cardiff School of Biosciences, JAMA Pediatrics, Mini-Reviews in Medicinal Chemistry, Cochrane Database of Systematic reviews, Alcohol Research, Explore og Flavour and Fragrance Journal.
Also read: Rising demand raises questions about who should use GLP-1 medicines
Also read: New review suggests nitrous oxide may reshape approaches to treatment-resistant depression