You've probably stood in the supermarket aisle, picked up a box and scanned the colored label on the front.
Most of us trust that if nothing is marked red, the product is a reasonable choice. That turns out to be a shaky assumption.
A new University College London study compared nearly 1,900 packaged foods sold in the UK against the government's own dietary guide.
By that yardstick, 95% of processed products and 98% of ultraprocessed products counted as unhealthy.
Also read: Stronger flu shot linked to 55% lower Alzheimer's risk
The research, published in the journal BMJ Medicine, then ran the same products through the labels and rules shoppers actually see.
Front-of-pack traffic light labels flagged only 48%. The regulator's HFSS model, which grades foods high in fat, salt and sugar, caught 58%.
Where the official systems disagree
The NHS Eatwell Guide is the UK's official picture of a balanced diet, built around vegetables, fruit, whole grains, pulses and lean proteins.
The traffic light system on the front of packs grades fat, saturated fat, sugar and salt per 100 grams as green, amber or red.
Also read: The FDA just approved a first-of-its-kind daily pill to prevent repeat strokes
The HFSS rules decide which products can be advertised to children or placed at checkout displays.
The gap in the new analysis is striking. Canned pasta in tomato sauce, packaged macaroni and cheese mix, and even fat-free probiotic yogurts fell on the unhealthy side of the Eatwell Guide but slipped past the traffic lights.
The Eatwell Guide looks at the whole pattern of what you eat, including whole fruit, vegetables, fiber, nuts and oily fish. The traffic lights only grade four nutrients per 100 grams.
That is why plain nuts and whole fruit can pick up an amber or red light for their natural sugar or fat, even though both are foods the guide actively recommends.
Also read: Researchers find that BMI may misclassify obesity risk in thousands of adults
What the researchers want to change
Lead author Sam Dicken, of UCL Epidemiology and Health Care, said current regulatory tools miss products loaded with harmful nutrients that the UK's dietary guidance would reject.
The research team argues for a single, unified system for classifying unhealthy food, aligned with existing dietary guidance.
Senior author Professor Chris van Tulleken said the UK food environment is saturated with products that make it hard for shoppers to eat in line with government advice.
What it means for your next grocery run
The practical takeaway crosses borders. Front-of-pack color labels and similar regulatory shortcuts can give a soft signal to foods a broader dietary guideline still considers poor choices.
Also read: Signs your winter fatigue could actually be seasonal depression
Treat front-of-pack labels as one hint, not a verdict. Scan the ingredient list and the saturated fat, salt and sugar numbers on the back of the pack.
A basket built around whole fruit, vegetables, legumes, whole grains and minimally processed proteins will usually land closer to the Eatwell Guide than to the front-of-pack color.
Also read: Scientists reveal how many steps you really need each day based on your age
This article is made and published by Ida-Marie Palm Varbæk, who may have used AI in the preparation.
