Researchers find that BMI may misclassify obesity risk in thousands of adults

Date:

Share this article:

Del denne artikel:

A study just redrew the line between a health risk and an actual illness, with a tape measure at the center.

You have probably heard that your BMI tells you whether you weigh too much.

Many people get flagged in the orange or red zone and start worrying about their health. For decades, the number on the scale has done most of the talking.

That may now be changing. A new study of 844,108 adults, published November 11, 2026, in Nature, found that a tape measure around your waist is essential for telling who is actually at serious health risk.

Researchers at King's College London compared the standard BMI label with a two-step approach that adds waist circumference and waist-to-height ratio. The result splits obesity into two very different groups.

Also read: Signs your winter fatigue could actually be seasonal depression

What the study actually found

Under the new definition, only about one in four people who look obese on the scale have what the researchers call clinical obesity.

That is obesity where excess fat is already damaging organ function, from the heart to the joints.

Across the four countries studied, China, the United Kingdom, the United States and Spain, between 5.6 and 10.9 percent of all adults met this stricter definition.

Most other people flagged as obese by BMI fell into a group called preclinical obesity.

Also read: Scientists reveal how many steps you really need each day based on your age

That distinction matters. Between 77 and 91 percent of people with preclinical obesity stayed stable over ten years, without progressing to clinical obesity. Their risk of early death went up only modestly.

Clinical obesity carried a much heavier toll. People in that group had a 69 percent higher risk of dying than people without obesity or related organ dysfunction.

Preclinical obesity raised that risk by about 19 percent.

Why BMI alone can miss the mark

BMI is just weight relative to height. It says nothing about where the fat sits, and fat around the organs is the dangerous kind.

Also read: Taking Ozempic or Wegovy? The FDA just added a vision-loss warning to the label

When the team compared BMI with BMI plus waist measures, BMI alone missed obesity-level body fat in up to 8.6 percent of people and wrongly flagged obesity in up to 3.1 percent.

The higher death risk only showed up when waist measurements were in the picture.

Professor Francesco Rubino, senior author and chair of metabolic and bariatric surgery, commented in a statement from King's College London in EurekAlert.

He said BMI alone leaves people "vulnerable to both undertreatment and overtreatment."

Also read: Five breathing techniques that may calm anxiety in just a few minutes

How to work out your own waist-to-height ratio

The method is simple. Measure around your waist at the level of the belly button, then divide by your height, using the same units. Keep your waist below half your height, and you are inside the healthy range.

For a 5-foot-10 adult (70 inches), that means keeping the waist under 35 inches. For a woman who stands 5-foot-5 (65 inches), the target is under 32.5 inches.

What this could mean for your care

The findings suggest many people labeled obese on the scale may not need urgent medical intervention.

At the same time, some people with a normal BMI but a thick waist may be at real health risk and currently go unnoticed.

Also read: How eating tomatoes every day may affect your heart and cancer risk

Anyone unsure where they fall can bring their waist-to-height ratio to their next check-up, especially alongside signs like high blood pressure, sleep apnea or difficulty with everyday movement.

This article is made and published by Ida-Marie Palm Varbæk, who may have used AI in the preparation.

Other articles

Signs your winter fatigue could actually be seasonal depression

If you brace yourself every fall for the dark months, doctors watch for a pattern that separates a slump from something more.

Scientists reveal how many steps you really need each day based on your age

The honest daily target shifts meaningfully by age, and the first few thousand steps matter far more than the last.

Taking Ozempic or Wegovy? The FDA just added a vision-loss warning to the label

Behind the label change is a single eye condition and a rate that quietly doubled compared with the trials' control groups.

Five breathing techniques that may calm anxiety in just a few minutes

All five patterns have research behind them, but one stood out for how fast it works.

Signs your winter fatigue could actually be seasonal depression

If you brace yourself every fall for the dark months, doctors watch for a pattern that separates a slump from something more.

Scientists reveal how many steps you really need each day based on your age

The honest daily target shifts meaningfully by age, and the first few thousand steps matter far more than the last.

Taking Ozempic or Wegovy? The FDA just added a vision-loss warning to the label

Behind the label change is a single eye condition and a rate that quietly doubled compared with the trials' control groups.