Why your therapy sessions may not be helping as much as you hoped

Date:

Share this article:

Del denne artikel:

A look at more than 33,000 people in therapy points to a mismatch between standard treatment and the symptoms most patients actually carry.

You may have tried therapy and walked away feeling it helped, but only a little.

Many people wonder if they picked the wrong therapist, or if they are simply hard to treat. New research points to a different possibility.

Researchers at Northeastern University analyzed 33,675 US adults who had sought psychotherapy for anxiety and depression.

Their findings, published in Psychological Medicine in August 2026, sort symptoms into patterns that cut across the usual diagnostic labels.

Also read: A new blood test could detect breast cancer earlier

More than half of the patients, about 56%, fell into what the authors call the worries cluster.

Their symptoms were driven by repetitive negative thinking and rumination about the future.

Another 16% fit a hyperarousal cluster, with restlessness, irritability and physical agitation.

Two smaller groups also emerged. About one in five patients carried an affective dysregulation pattern of depressed mood and loss of pleasure.

Also read: She monitored her blood sugar for 30 days: Here's what surprised her

Around one in eight showed a neurovegetative pattern with changes in sleep, appetite and energy.

The problem with one-size-fits-all treatment

Standard care usually anchors itself to a diagnosis.

Everyone with generalized anxiety gets one protocol. Everyone with major depression gets another.

The team then followed 10,718 of the patients through 12 weeks of message-based therapy.

Also read: How eating eggs five times a week may lower your Alzheimer's risk

Just under a third reached full recovery. Another third made partial progress. The last third did not respond.

Patients in the worries and hyperarousal clusters had the best odds of recovering.

Those in the affective dysregulation and neurovegetative clusters fared worse, even when their overall symptom score looked similar at the start.

What symptom-focused therapy looks like

Cognitive behavioral therapy, often called CBT, teaches patients to notice automatic unhelpful thoughts and change the behaviors tied to them.

Also read: Research reveals how to build muscle more effectively after 40

The National Institute of Mental Health describes it as an evidence-based approach for reducing symptoms of both anxiety and depression.

The newer twist is matching the CBT technique to the dominant symptom.

A patient whose main issue is replaying the same worries might benefit from a rumination-focused version of CBT.

A 2024 review in Frontiers in Psychology concluded it reduced depressive symptoms across trials, though the authors noted it has not clearly outperformed standard CBT head to head.

Also read: These sleep mistakes could be affecting your mood

For patients whose anxiety shows up as physical restlessness or irritability, exposure-based CBT and arousal-targeting techniques may be a better match.

The Northeastern team argues that targeting the dominant cluster could disrupt several symptoms at once.

If therapy has not moved the needle, patients can ask their clinician whether the plan is targeting their most dominant symptom pattern.

That could be repetitive worry, physical restlessness, low mood or disrupted sleep, rather than only the diagnosis on the chart.

This article is made and published by Ida-Marie Palm Varbæk, who may have used AI in the preparation.

Other articles

A new blood test could detect breast cancer earlier

Scientists say a few drops of plasma may one day pick up tumors that mammograms miss, and even hint at which patients need closer watching.

She monitored her blood sugar for 30 days: Here’s what surprised her

How do food, exercise, sleep, and stress actually affect blood sugar levels? That is what 33-year-old journalist Alexa...

How eating eggs five times a week may lower your Alzheimer’s risk

A new long-term study of older Americans asked how often they ate eggs, and the answer may change what you put on your breakfast plate.

Research reveals how to build muscle more effectively after 40

After 40, the rules shift, and a few targeted adjustments to training and protein decide whether you lose ground or keep gaining it.

A new blood test could detect breast cancer earlier

Scientists say a few drops of plasma may one day pick up tumors that mammograms miss, and even hint at which patients need closer watching.

She monitored her blood sugar for 30 days: Here’s what surprised her

How do food, exercise, sleep, and stress actually affect blood sugar levels? That is what 33-year-old journalist Alexa...

How eating eggs five times a week may lower your Alzheimer’s risk

A new long-term study of older Americans asked how often they ate eggs, and the answer may change what you put on your breakfast plate.