Whether you push through a 6 a.m. session or an after-work sweat may matter more than most fitness advice suggests.
A randomized controlled trial published in Frontiers in Physiology in May 2022 found that the ideal exercise window depends both on your sex and on the outcome you care about most.
Researchers at Skidmore College put healthy, active adults through 12 weeks of the same multi-modal program.
One group trained between 6 and 8 a.m., the other between 6:30 and 8:30 p.m.
Also read: If you drink alcohol, the type you choose may affect your heart risk
The workouts combined resistance training, interval sprints, stretching and endurance work, four sessions a week.
The only variable that changed was the clock.
What the morning group gained
Women who trained in the morning came out ahead on two measures that clinicians watch closely.
Their abdominal fat fell by about 10 percent, compared with roughly 3 percent in the evening group.
Also read: 8 in 10 young cancer patients found it themselves. Doctors missed the signs
Systolic blood pressure dropped by about 12.5 mmHg in the morning exercisers, while the evening group's reading barely moved.
Diastolic pressure showed a similar tilt toward the morning slot.
For the men in the trial, morning workouts did not deliver the same edge on either measure.
Their body composition and blood pressure changes were modest whether they trained early or late.
Also read: Over 70 and heart-healthy? A daily statin may still cut your heart attack risk by 30%
What the evening group gained
The evening slot rewarded different goals.
Women who trained after work made bigger gains in upper-body strength and power.
Their bench press one-rep max, upper-body peak power and push-up counts all rose more than in the morning group.
Evening exercisers also reported better mood after their sessions, while the morning group showed no mood shift.
Also read: 8 warning signs of SIBO most people mistake for IBS or a sensitive gut
Men saw the clearest evening payoff on cardiometabolic markers.
Systolic blood pressure fell by about 14.9 mmHg in the evening group, compared with 3.5 mmHg in the morning group.
The evening exercisers also burned a notably higher share of energy from fat during the workout, a shift the researchers linked to improved metabolic efficiency.
A separate look at afternoon endurance
A second study published two months later in Frontiers in Endocrinology looked only at endurance exercise, and only at men.
Also read: If you take Ambien or a sleep aid, these foods and drinks may work against you
Twelve healthy young men walked on a treadmill for an hour at moderate intensity, either at 9 a.m. or at 4 p.m., in a crossover design.
Late-afternoon sessions produced significantly lower 24-hour glucose levels than the morning sessions and also improved triglycerides, a blood-fat marker tied to heart disease.
Morning exercise did not move those markers to the same extent.
Because that trial did not include women, the findings cannot be extended to them.
What this means for your week
Both trials are small, and the Skidmore study recruited people who were already highly active, so the numbers may not translate one-to-one to a beginner.
Consistency still matters more than perfect timing.
If you do have the flexibility to pick a window, the pattern is worth knowing.
A morning session may suit a woman focused on abdominal fat or on lowering blood pressure.
An evening slot may suit a woman working on upper-body strength, or a man targeting blood pressure and fat metabolism.
Anyone starting a program with existing high blood pressure or a metabolic condition should talk with their doctor first, since the numbers above come from healthy participants and not from people already on treatment.
This article is made and published by Ida-Marie Palm Varbæk, who may have used AI in the preparation.