You probably know the drill after a tough workout. Your legs ache, the stairs feel longer than they should, and everyone has an opinion on how to fix it. Some people reach for an ice bath, others swear by a hot bath or a sauna.
A new trial published in the Journal of Thermal Biology and led by researchers at the University of East London put four recovery methods head to head. Over 72 hours, none of them restored muscle strength faster than simply resting.
The team put 40 physically active adults through heavy leg exercises designed to cause muscle damage. Then they tested four recovery routes side by side.
One group sat in cold water around 50°F. Another soaked in hot water at 108°F. A third spent time in a sauna-like hot-air cabin. The fourth group simply rested.
Also read: Why your therapy sessions may not be helping as much as you hoped
What cold water actually did
Strength dropped by about 36 percent in every group right after the exercise. By 72 hours later, the cold-water group had recovered least, climbing back to around 82 percent of baseline. The other three groups landed closer to 88 or 89 percent.
Cold still pulled its weight on one measure. People in the cold-water group reported feeling less sore, even though their muscles were not objectively ahead of the others.
That split matters. Feeling recovered and being recovered are not the same thing, and a lower soreness score can still make the next session easier to face.
Where heat quietly came out on top
Heat moved biological markers that cold did not. Heat shock protein 72, a cellular protection system that helps repair stressed muscle, rose in the hot-water and hot-air groups.
Also read: A new blood test could detect breast cancer earlier
Creatine kinase-MM, a damage marker that leaks out of broken-down muscle fibers, dropped back toward baseline faster in the heat groups than in the cold group.
That pattern fits a broader body of work. A 2025 review in Sports Medicine, Open pooled 14 trials on post-exercise heat exposure. Regular heat exposure may help endurance performance over time, though effects on a single workout remain inconsistent.
When cold may work against your gains
If you lift to build muscle, timing matters. A landmark trial in the Journal of Physiology trained men for 12 weeks with either an ice bath or light cycling after every leg session. The cold-water group ended up with smaller gains in muscle size and strength.
Later research has backed up the pattern. Jumping into cold water soon after resistance work appears to dampen the anabolic signals that tell muscles to grow.
Also read: She monitored her blood sugar for 30 days: Here's what surprised her
How to pick cold or heat for your goal
If you want to feel less sore between hard sessions, a cold plunge may help your perception even when the biology lags behind.
If you are building muscle, keep ice baths away from the hours right after your lifting session so you do not blunt the anabolic signal.
For endurance athletes preparing to compete in heat, repeated heat exposure after workouts may offer a small edge by the time race day arrives.
Also read: How eating eggs five times a week may lower your Alzheimer's risk
Also read: Research reveals how to build muscle more effectively after 40
This article is made and published by Mie Hermansen, who may have used AI in the preparation.
